The American Humanist Association's Shay Leonia on discovering humanism through a job posting, learning out loud, and meeting people where they are.
"I've never heard of humanism, but is this what I've been all along?" What happens when you discover the word for what you've believed your whole life? Shay Leonia came to humanism only recently, and rather than hide the learning curve, she has made it the heart of her work. In this episode, James Hodgson talks with Shay about her journey into humanism, the art of admitting what you don't know, and how to bring humanist values to people who have never heard the term.
We discuss growing up with everyday kindness as a lived value, letting go of the supernatural without losing what matters, the AHA Creator Program and building coalitions beyond the secular space, and why humanism needs to become more accessible and more representative if it is going to grow.
About the guest
Shay Leonia is the communications manager at the American Humanist Association (AHA), where she hosts the How to Humanist podcast and runs AHA's Creator Program, partnering with content creators to bring humanism to new audiences. A lifelong musician based in Philadelphia, she founded the media company 44th Minute Media and came to humanism recently, arriving, as she puts it, curious, a little confused, and glad she stayed.
In this episode
- How Shay discovered humanism through a job posting and realised it named the values she'd held all along
- Learning out loud: the "fourth wall break" behind How to Humanist, and why admitting what you don't know builds trust
- The AHA Creator Program, giving people a "soft landing" into humanism, and why the movement must become more accessible and representative
Chapters 00:00 Introduction: meet Shay Leonia
01:18 Growing up, and early humanist values
03:11 A reformed Jewish upbringing
04:01 Discovering humanism through a job posting
05:17 Learning humanism in public
06:00 Talking across belief systems, and reforming your own views
08:53 Letting go of the supernatural
10:05 Breaking the fourth wall on How to Humanist
14:39 The AHA Creator Program
17:12 Building coalitions beyond the secular space
19:59 Giving people a "soft landing" into humanism
22:57 Humanism's blind spots: accessibility and representation
25:51 What role should the AHA play?
28:24 Advice for talking with allies
31:04 Leading with curiosity and compassion
31:32 Changing minds and letting go
Links and references
- How to Humanist podcast: https://americanhumanist.org/how-to-humanist-podcast/
- American Humanist Association: https://americanhumanist.org
- Greg Epstein, Good Without God (mentioned in the episode): https://www.gregmepstein.com
Check out our new website and subscribe for updates: www.humanism.now
Support Humanism Now and join our community
Follow @HumanismNowPod on YouTube | TikTok | Instagram | Facebook | Threads | X | Bluesky
Humanism Now is produced by Humanise Live, a podcast production agency based in London, serving charities, companies and individuals across the globe. To start your own podcast, visit humanise.live or email hello@humanise.live.
Music: Blossom by Light Prism
Podcast transcripts are AI-generated and may contain errors or omissions. They are provided to make our content more accessible and should not be treated as a fully accurate record of the conversation.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Communications Manager - American Humanist Association
Shay Leonia (she/her) is the Communications Manager for the American Humanist Association, where hosting and producing the podcast How to Humanist and running AHA’s Creator Program are among the work she does to get humanist ideas in front of people who might not know there’s a home for them. She also facilitates workshops and conversations built on the conviction that humanism belongs to everyone, not just the people who already have the vocabulary for it.
Shay came to humanism through her Jewish mother, whose lifelong instinct for warmth and generosity toward strangers Shay didn’t recognize as Humanism until years later — a story she tells in full in the debut episode of How to Humanist.
Raised in a household of professional musicians and inevitably becoming one herself, Shay balances her work at AHA with an ongoing music career, including her work as a wedding singer. A graduate of The American Musical and Dramatic Academy (NYC), she’s sung alongside Janelle Monáe on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, performed for VH1’s RuPaul’s Drag Race, and recorded with legends like The Pharcyde, Treach of Naughty by Nature, Monifah and more.
Outside of her work, Shay is a vocal advocate for women’s sexual liberation, a free Palestine, and believing Black women. She remains a firm believer in humor as a remedy for just about everything else. Possibly thanks to her lifelong proximity to New York City, her “make ’em laugh” approach has followed her to Philadelphia, where she now resides, Jersey accent fully intact.
Castbox
Overcast
Deezer
Podchaser
PlayerFM
Castro
TuneIn